Add the vanilla extract and peanut butter. With a spatula chop up the peanut butter to more evenly spread it through the mix
Add your water tablespoon by tablespoon and continue to mix and fold until the mixture is able to be molded. You should have a nice block of mixture to work with and be able to pick up.
Break off pieces of the block and roll into a ball. Continue to do this until all the mixture is used.
Eat and enjoy! Store in an airtight container.